the citation graph
MAKUCHYAN AND MINASYAN v. AZERBAIJAN AND HUNGARY
2020-05-26 · European Court of Human Rights · Council of Europe
13What it rests on
12Relied on since
0Departed from
Relied on since
The judgments that cite this one. This is the answer that tells you the case is still alive.
20211 judgments20234 judgments20243 judgments20251 judgments20263 judgments
12 judgments have relied on it, across 2021–2026
first 2021 · last 2026 · busiest 2023 (4 judgments)
2026-05-28KOVALENKO v. UKRAINEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2026-02-03BEGIĆ v. BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2026-02-03NAVALNYY v. RUSSIA (No. 4)European Court of Human Rightsfollowed2025-09-18FARMANYAN AND OTHERS v. ARMENIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2024-11-07BAKRADZE v. GEORGIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2024-05-28ZAREMA MUSAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2024-04-23ZĂICESCU AND FĂLTICINEANU v. ROMANIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2023-12-19NARAYAN AND OTHERS v. AZERBAIJANEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2023-11-07DURDAJ AND OTHERS v. ALBANIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2023-10-24MEMEDOVA AND OTHERS v. NORTH MACEDONIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2023-07-13EMIN HUSEYNOV v. AZERBAIJAN (No. 2)European Court of Human Rights2021-09-21CARTER v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed
What it rests on
2015-06-16SARGSYAN v. AZERBAIJANEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2013-11-28DVORSKI v. CROATIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2010-01-07RANTSEV v. CYPRUS AND RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2009-08-25GIULIANI AND GAGGIO v. ITALYEuropean Court of Human Rights2008-03-20BUDAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2005-12-13TIMISHEV v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2004-12-20MAKARATZIS v. GREECEEuropean Court of Human Rights2004-04-08ASSANIDZE v. GEORGIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2004-02-26NACHOVA AND OTHERS v. BULGARIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2002-06-13ANGUELOVA v. BULGARIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2000-07-11JABARI v. TURKEYEuropean Court of Human Rights2000-05-18VELIKOVA v. BULGARIAEuropean Court of Human Rights1979-10-09AIREY v. IRELANDEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed
43 point outside the corpus. Read from the text, but no judgment held here answers to them. They are counted rather than hidden: this corpus is a slice, not the law.
Adam v. Slovakia, no. 68066/12Al Hamdani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina, no. 31098/10Aliyeva and Aliyev v. Azerbaijan, no. 35587/08Al Nashiri v. Romania, no. 33234/12Angelova and Iliev v. Bulgaria, no. 55523/00Atiman v. Turkey, no. 62279/09Avotins v. Latvia [GC], no. 17502/07Baysakov and Others v. Ukraine, no. 54131/08Berktay v. Turkey, no. 22493/93Bitiyeva and X v. Russia, nos. 57953/00Chiragov and Others v. Armenia [GC], no. 13216/05Ciorcan and Others v. Romania, nos. 29414/09Denis Vasilyev v. Russia, no. 32704/04Dimitrov and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 77938/11Duran v. Turkey, no. 42942/02Eon v. France, no. 26118/10Fergec v. Croatia, no. 68516/14Finger v. Bulgaria, no. 37346/05Gagliano Giorgi v. Italy, no. 23563/07Gaysanova v. Russia, no. 62235/09Giusti v. Italy, no. 13175/03Gorovenky and Bugara v. Ukraine, nos. 36146/05Gray v. Germany, no. 49278/09Hummatov v. Azerbaijan, nos. 9852/03