the citation graph
MURTAZALIYEVA v. RUSSIA
2018-12-18 · European Court of Human Rights · Council of Europe
24What it rests on
16Relied on since
0Departed from
Relied on since
The judgments that cite this one. This is the answer that tells you the case is still alive.
20191 judgments20201 judgments20232 judgments20247 judgments20254 judgments20261 judgments
16 judgments have relied on it, across 2019–2026
first 2019 · last 2026 · busiest 2024 (7 judgments)
2026-06-16ISKRENOVIĆ v. SERBIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2025-12-09AYKAÇ v. TÜRKİYEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2025-07-17OPALENKO v. UKRAINEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2025-07-17Y.K. v. CROATIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2025-04-29JAUPI v. ALBANIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2024-12-05KEZERASHVILI v. GEORGIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2024-11-26SOUROULLAS KAY AND ZANNETTOS v. CYPRUSEuropean Court of Human Rights2024-10-15H.T. v. GERMANY AND GREECEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2024-08-29KHACHAPURIDZE AND KHACHIDZE v. GEORGIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2024-08-27W.R. v. THE NETHERLANDSEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2024-03-05LEKA v. ALBANIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2024-02-15ŠKOBERNE v. SLOVENIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2023-09-26YÜKSEL YALÇINKAYA v. TÜRKİYEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2023-06-29KHAVSHABOVA v. GEORGIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2020-10-15MUHAMMAD AND MUHAMMAD v. ROMANIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2019-06-18CHERNEGA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed
What it rests on
2015-10-20SIMEONOVI v. BULGARIAEuropean Court of Human Rights×3followed2014-04-17SCHATSCHASCHWILI v. GERMANYEuropean Court of Human Rights×22013-11-28DVORSKI v. CROATIAEuropean Court of Human Rights2013-11-26AL-DULIMI AND MONTANA MANAGEMENT INC. v. SWITZERLANDEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2010-11-02SAKHNOVSKIY v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2009-03-10BYKOV v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2009-01-13TAXQUET v. BELGIUMEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2008-11-27SALDUZ v. TURKEYEuropean Court of Human Rights2008-07-24VLADIMIR ROMANOV v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2007-11-15GALSTYAN v. ARMENIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2007-07-12JORGIC v. GERMANYEuropean Court of Human Rights2006-07-11JALLOH v. GERMANYEuropean Court of Human Rights2005-05-12ÖCALAN v. TURKEYEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed2004-02-12PEREZ v. FRANCEEuropean Court of Human Rights×2followed2003-05-06PERNA v. ITALYEuropean Court of Human Rights1999-12-14A.M. v. ITALYEuropean Court of Human Rights1996-02-08JOHN MURRAY v. THE UNITED KINGDOMEuropean Court of Human Rights1991-03-19CARDOT v. FRANCEEuropean Court of Human Rights1990-12-19DELTA v. FRANCEEuropean Court of Human Rights1989-07-07BRICMONT v. BELGIUMEuropean Court of Human Rights1986-11-24UNTERPERTINGER v. AUSTRIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed1984-04-09GODDI v. ITALYEuropean Court of Human Rights1980-05-13ARTICO v. ITALYEuropean Court of Human Rights1980-02-27DEWEER v. BELGIUMEuropean Court of Human Rights
62 point outside the corpus. Read from the text, but no judgment held here answers to them. They are counted rather than hidden: this corpus is a slice, not the law.
Correia de Matos v. Portugal [GC], no. 56402/12 ×2Dorokhov v. Russia, no. 66802/01 ×2Ioan Rusu v. Romania, no. 22767/08 ×2Khametshin v. Russia, no. 18487/03 ×2Miminoshvili v. Russia, no. 20197/03 ×2Pello v. Estonia, no. 11423/03 ×2Polufakin and Chernyshev v. Russia, no. 30997/02 ×2Popov v. Russia, no. 26853/04 ×2Sergey Afanasyev v. Ukraine, no. 48057/06 ×2Tarasov v. Ukraine, no. 17416/03 ×2Tymchenko v. Ukraine, no. 47351/06 ×2Andrey Zakharov v. Ukraine, no. 26581/06April 2010. 72. Pishchalnikov v. Russia, no. 7025/04Artner v. Austria, no. 13161/87Asch v. Austria, no. 12398/86Bannikova v. Russia, no. 18757/06Beraru v. Romania, no. 40107/04Boldea v. Romania, no. 19997/02Contrast Guilloury v. France, no. 62236/00Cutean v. Romania, no. 53150/12Damir Sibgatullin v. Russia, no. 1413/05Destrehem v. France, no. 56651/00ECHR 2003-V. 2. Compare Makeyev v. Russia, no. 13769/04Gabrielyan v. Armenia, no. 8088/05